REVIEW PAPER
The general clause "interest of service" as one of the grounds for optional dismissal from service on the example of a police officer - selected theoretical and case law aspects
More details
Hide details
1
WSEI University, Poland
Submission date: 2024-04-26
Acceptance date: 2024-07-11
Publication date: 2024-08-20
JoMS 2024;57(Numer specjalny 3):241-255
KEYWORDS
TOPICS
ABSTRACT
The principles of employing Police officers are regulated by the Act of April 6, 1990 on the Police, professional pragmatics of an autonomous nature. In the discussed pragmatics, the legislator divided the exhaustive catalog of reasons for dismissal from service into two reasons - obligatory and optional. The impetus for undertaking the research issues covered in this article was the construction of one of the reasons for optional dismissal from service. Namely, in accordance with Art. 41 section 2 point 5 of the Police Act, a police officer may be dismissed from service when an important interest of the service requires it. The construction of the service's interest is nothing more than the normative construction of a general clause, which by its nature is unspecified. Therefore, the closed catalog of grounds for dismissal from service remains open in this respect. The legislator deliberately and consciously uses this construction to make the generally closed catalog of reasons for dismissal from service more flexible. It should be stated, however, that although the Police authority is provided with a large area of freedom in the process of applying the law, the clause in question is not the basis for the authority to make arbitrary and instrumental assessments. The service interest clause, despite its undefined nature, refers to extra-legal criteria with a semantic context defined by the name of the criterion.
REFERENCES (10)
1.
Arytsoteles. (2008). Nicomachean Ethics, Warsaw.
2.
Gacek, P. (2011). Establishing a service relationship with a police officer. Administracja Teoria Dydaktyka Praktyka, 23 no. 2.
3.
Korybski, A., Leszczyński, L. (2021).Introduction to jurisprudence.
5.
Kuczyński, T., Mazurczak-Jasińska, E., Stelina, J. (2011). Service relationship, [in:] System of administrative law, vol.11.
6.
Leszczyński, L. (2016). General reference clauses – theoretical and legal approach, Annales UMCS, Sectio G, Vol. LXIII, No. 2.
7.
Paśnik, J. (2020). Important interest of the service and the needs of the armed forces as grounds for terminating the service relationship with an officer and a professional soldier: selected issues of theory and practice [in:] Guarantees of individual rights in administrative and administrative court proceedings, pp. 229-242.
8.
Szot, A. (2016). General clause as a cross-branch structure of the legal system, Annales UMCS, Sectio G, Vol. LXIII, no. 2, p. 291.
9.
Wieczorek, M. (2017). Legal nature of service relations of uniformed service officers, Toruń: Wydawnictwo Adam Marszałek.
10.
Witoszko, W. (2021). Important interest of service as a reason for dismissal from service in the nature of a general clause, Białystok Studia Prawnicze vol. 26 no. 2.